Improve your business
Guides & Templates
Contractor Taxes Vs Employee Taxes: Breaking Down the Complexities for Your Benefit

Contractor Taxes Vs Employee Taxes: Breaking Down the Complexities for Your Benefit

Get the lowdown on contractor taxes vs. employee taxes with expert insights. Find your way through IRS guidelines, understand the real deal with misclassification, and make smart moves for your financial journey.


Taxes can be a pain, no matter if you're an employee or a contractor. Even employers have to deal with payroll taxes when they hire someone. But the truth is, the difference between being an independent contractor versus an employee can have a big impact on your tax bill.

Whether you're just starting out as an independent contractor, or you're a small business owner trying to understand the payroll tax implications for your employees, this guide is for you. 

We'll break down the government rules for determining employee vs. contractor status, explain the different types of taxes that each group pays, and discuss the pros and cons of each. 

By the end of this guide, you'll have a solid understanding of how independent contractor taxes and employee taxes work. And you'll be able to make informed decisions about your own employment status.

And as a bonus, we’ll also provide you with an automation tool that will help you stay organized and keep your business finances balanced.

1099 vs. W2 Employee: What’s the Difference?

The main difference between a 1099 employee and a W2 employee lies in how they work and are treated by their employers. An independent contractor is usually a self-employed individual who offers their services to various clients. They have more control over when and how they work, often setting their own hours and using their own tools.

On the other hand, a W2 employee is hired by a company to work under their direction and supervision. They typically work set hours, follow company guidelines, and may be paid a salary or hourly wage.

Understanding IRS Guidelines for Employees vs. Contractors and Avoiding Misclassification

Federal employment laws set a clear boundary between these positions, and their effects carry a substantial impact on taxes, benefits, and legal rights for workers. Understanding the IRS guidelines for deciding whether someone is an employee or a contractor is vital to avoid confusion and financial issues.

Essentially, there are three main aspects to consider:

1. Behavioral Control: This boils down to how much the company tells the worker what to do and how to do it.

2. Financial Control: This takes a look at how much control the business has over the financial and operational sides of the worker's gig. It includes payment methods, expense reimbursements, and who provides the necessary tools or supplies.

3. Relationship of the Parties: This aspect explores the formal agreements and employee benefits that might be in play, like insurance or vacation pay. Plus, it takes into account whether the work is vital to the business's core.

While the IRS certainly wields authority in the realm of independent contractor classification, it's not the sole decision maker. Other federal entities, like the Department of Labor, and even state governments, have their own say in how workers should be classified. 

Interestingly, their verdicts might sometimes differ from the IRS's stance. Because of the potential pitfalls, it's highly recommended that independent contractors and businesses seek legal advice to navigate this classification puzzle.

That said, for employers, classifying their workers is a big deal. You see, misclassifying workers as contractors when they're actually employees can lead to some serious headaches. It means you're not paying the right taxes and not covering them with things like worker compensation and unemployment insurance. 

Businesses that misclassify employees are likely to have to reimburse unpaid taxes, such as overtime, minimum wage, federal and state income taxes, Social Security, Medicare, unemployment taxes, and even employee benefits like health insurance and retirement plans. 

Keep in mind that misclassification doesn't just affect employers. It hits W2 employees too. If you’re an employee but you’re labeled a contractor, you miss out on certain employee benefits and protections. 

On the other hand, if you're an independent contract employee who's been slapped with the traditional "employee" label but you haven’t been paying your taxes accordingly, you risk an audit and penalties.

Note: If you think you've been misclassified, you can file Form 8919 with the IRS. This form will help you calculate the amount of unpaid Social Security and Medicare taxes that you owe. You can also contact your state labor department to file a complaint. They may be able to help you get the benefits and protections that you're entitled to.

Misclassification can have serious consequences for both businesses and workers. By understanding the IRS guidelines and taking the time to classify workers correctly, you can help to avoid these problems.

Taxes for Employees vs. Independent Contractors

Whether you're hired as an employee, or take a gig as an independent contractor, or run a small business and are trying to wrap your head around what you need to do as an employer, taxes are a certainty in both the USA and Canada. However, the rules and responsibilities vary significantly between the two. 

Let's dive into the tax world and see how it shakes out in the USA and Canada for both of these roles.

How Taxes Work in the United States

American Employees:

For employees, life's a bit simpler. Employers automatically withhold federal and state taxes, and often even contribute to Social Security and Medicare tax. At tax time, you'll receive a Form W-2, summarizing your earnings and taxes paid. You’ll simply plug these numbers into your tax return, or have your tax accountant handle it for you.

American Independent Contractors:

Working as a 1099 contractor in the United States means taxes can be a bit more intricate. Unlike employees, you're responsible for setting aside a chunk of your earnings for taxes. This includes not just income tax, but also self-employment tax, which covers Medicare and Social Security—things employers normally take care of. While self-employed contractors might have a slightly higher tax rate on paper, they often end up paying less overall due to business tax deductions and breaks.

One thing that works in favor of freelancers is that they only pay tax on their profits, not their total earnings. A wide array of business expenses can be deducted, such as home office supplies, marketing costs, hardware like laptops and cameras, travel expenses, and even meals and entertainment related to your work.

Freelancers also need to be on the ball when it comes to tax forms. Instead of one annual payment, you'll likely make quarterly estimated tax payments using Form 1040-ES (if you make over a certain amount). Another common form you'll come across is Form 1099-NEC (Nonemployee Compensation), which shows how much you've earned from different gigs.

How Taxes Work in Canada

Canadian Employees:

In Canada, employee taxes follow a structured pattern. The first chunk of your income is tax-free, and then progressive rates apply as you earn more. Employers handle your tax withholding and contributions to the Canadian Pension Plan (CPP) and Employment Insurance (EI). Come tax season, you'll receive a T4 slip, which details your earnings and deductions.

Canadian Independent Contractors:

Again, working as a contractor means taxes take on a whole different form. Independent contractors in Canada need to consider income tax, CPP payments, and possibly Employment Insurance contributions. 

Canadian freelancers should ideally put away around 30% of their income for taxes. You can also choose between operating as a sole contractor or setting up a company to optimize tax benefits and claim business expenses throughout the year.

Bottom line: Whether you're an employee or an independent contractor in either Canada or the United States, understanding your tax responsibilities is essential. While employees may have the luxury of automatic tax deductions, freelancers can tap into deductions and flexibility to manage their tax burdens. Remember, when in doubt, it's wise to consult a tax professional to guide you through the complexities of your tax journey.

Navigating Tax Filing and Reporting as an Independent Contractor or Business Owner

It's clear that being an independent contractor requires a lot more tax know-how compared to a traditional employee. And if you're an employer, managing your own employees' taxes adds another layer of complexity. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you navigate tax filing and reporting: 

American Independent Contractors

Step 1: Gather Your Documents:

Start by collecting all your financial records, including 1099 forms from clients, receipts for business expenses, and any other relevant financial documents.

Step 2: Understand Schedule C:

Schedule C is your go-to form for reporting your income and deductions as an independent contractor. It helps you calculate your business profit or loss, which then flows into your personal tax return.

Step 3: Fill Out Schedule SE:

Schedule SE is where you'll compute your self-employment tax, covering Social Security and Medicare contributions. This is the tax that employees and employers typically split, but as an independent contractor, it's all on you.

Step 4: Calculate Estimated Taxes:

Since you don't have an employer withholding taxes, you'll need to estimate your tax liability and make quarterly payments using Form 1040-ES. This "pay-as-you-go" system keeps you from getting hit with a big tax bill later.

Step 5: Keep Impeccable Records:

Keep your financial records well-organized and hold onto detailed receipts for all your business expenses (an automated tool can be a real game-changer here). This not only makes tax time less of a hassle but also lets you make the most of your deductions. 

American Employers with Employees

Step 1: Withhold Taxes:

As an employer, you're responsible for withholding federal income tax, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax from your employees’ paychecks. Use Form W-4 to determine the correct withholding amount.

Step 2: Report Wages and Taxes:

As part of your hiring process, it's important to report employee wages and withheld taxes to both the IRS and your state's tax agency. Utilize Form W-2 to provide your employees with their earnings and tax information.

Step 3: Pay Your Share:

Employers also contribute to Social Security and Medicare on behalf of their employees. This is a shared responsibility, with employers covering a portion of these taxes.

Step 4: Organize Records:

Maintain accurate records of employee wages, taxes withheld, and any benefits provided. Having organized records helps you stay compliant with tax regulations.

Reporting Independent Contractor Income to the IRS

When hiring independent contractors, it's just as important to handle tax obligations. Use Form 1099-NEC to report the total payments you've made to them during the tax year. This form, tailored for non-employee compensation, ensures your hiring processes are well-documented.

Canadian Tax Filing

Canadian Independent Contractors:

In Canada, individuals operating as independent contractors have the responsibility of reporting their business earnings and expenses through the utilization of the T2125 form. 

For those working as freelancers or contractors, it's essential to acquaint themselves with form T4A, also known as the Statement of Pension, Retirement, Annuity, and Other Income. This T4A form is specifically designed for self-employment income, aiding individuals in maintaining a comprehensive record of their earnings per client or project over the course of the year.

Typically, an independent contractor or freelancer will receive a T4 slip from each client they've worked with during the designated tax period. These slips offer a consolidated amount for each project completed, enabling you to effectively monitor and document your income, facilitating the calculation of taxes owed.

Canadian Employers:

Canadian employers must deduct income tax, CPP, and Employment Insurance (EI) premiums from their employees' paychecks. They also need to contribute their share of CPP and EI. Employers are required to provide T4 slips to employees, summarizing their earnings and deductions.

Navigating tax filing and reporting on both sides of the border, whether you're an independent contract employee, a full-time employee, or an employer, can be complex. However, understanding the specific requirements for different work arrangements and seeking professional advice when needed can make the tax journey far less daunting.

Self-Employed FAQs: Common Questions About Contractor Taxes and More 

How much taxes do I deduct as an independent contractor?

As a 1099 worker, you'll need to set aside about 25-30% of your income for taxes. 

What can you write off as an independent contractor?

You can write off various business-related expenses, like home office costs, travel expenses, equipment, supplies, and even a portion of health insurance premiums.

Do I need a W-2 as an independent contractor?

No, you won't receive a W-2. Instead, clients might send you a 1099 tax form if they paid you more than $600 during the tax year.

Do independent contractors get tax refunds?

Yes, they can. If you overpaid your estimated taxes, you might receive a refund just like employees do.

How do I report independent contractor income to the IRS?

You must report your independent contractor income on Schedule C of your Form 1040. You can also use Form 1099-MISC to report your income to the IRS if you receive payments of $600 or more from a client during the year.

What is the minimum amount to file taxes as an independent contractor?

If you have net earnings of $400 or more from self-employment, you are required to file taxes as an independent contractor.

How do you show income if self-employed?

You can show your income as a 1099 contract employee by providing documentation of your earnings, such as invoices, receipts, and bank statements. You can also use Schedule C of your Form 1040 to report your income.

How do contractors receive money?

Contractors usually receive payments through checks, electronic transfers, or direct deposits, depending on their clients' preferences.

Is working as a contractor worth it?

Working as a contractor has pros like flexibility and the potential for higher earnings. But it also means more responsibility for taxes and managing your own business affairs.

Do contractors make a lot of money?

Earnings vary widely based on skills, industry, and demand. Some contractors can make substantial income, while others might have fluctuating earnings.

What is the highest-paying contractor job?

The highest-paying contractor jobs can include roles like specialized engineers, IT consultants, management consultants, and skilled tradespeople.

Why do companies hire subcontractors?

Companies hire subcontractors for specialized skills on specific projects without the commitment of full-time employees. It helps manage costs and workload fluctuations.

Working As A Contractor vs. Employee: Pros and Cons

Determining whether to be an employee or an independent contractor is a crucial decision, and it's important to weigh the factors that align with your situation and preferences. Let's break down some key aspects to consider:

Job Security

As an employee, you generally have more stability in terms of job security. You have a steady income, benefits, and the comfort of knowing that your position is more structured and protected by labor laws. On the other hand, as a contract employee, job security can be more variable. While you might enjoy the flexibility of working on different projects, it might also mean dealing with uncertain income streams and the possibility of not having work lined up consistently.


Full-time employees often receive comprehensive benefits packages, including health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, and other perks. These benefits can provide a safety net during medical emergencies and retirement. As an independent contractor, you're responsible for obtaining your own benefits, which can be costly. However, you do have the flexibility to choose the plans that suit your needs and circumstances.

Work Arrangement Preferences

The nature of your work and your personal preferences also play a role. If you thrive on structure and a consistent routine, an employee role might suit you better. This arrangement provides a clear division between work hours and personal time. On the other hand, if you value flexibility and the ability to manage your own schedule, working as an independent contractor can grant you more control over your work-life balance.

Income and Taxes

As an employee, your income is consistent, and taxes are usually withheld from your paycheck, providing a sense of stability. However, you might pay a higher percentage of your income in taxes due to limited deductions. As a contractor, you have more control over your income and can potentially take advantage of various tax deductions available to business owners. However, you're responsible for managing your own taxes, including estimated tax payments.

Contract Labor Laws

Different labor laws apply to employees and independent contractors. Employees are protected by various regulations, including minimum wage, overtime pay, and anti-discrimination laws. Independent contractors have more flexibility in setting their own terms but are not covered by the same protections.

In the end, the decision between being a traditional employee or an independent employee depends on your unique circumstances, priorities, and preferences. If you value job security, stable benefits, and a structured work environment, being a W2 employee might be the right choice. 

On the other hand, if you seek flexibility, autonomy, and the potential for greater income control, working as an independent contractor could align better with your goals. It's crucial to carefully evaluate these factors to make an informed decision that suits your individual needs and aspirations.

Stay on Top of Your Tax Obligations and Business Needs with Automation Tools

As you navigate the dynamic landscape of work and taxation, it's important to stay informed and make decisions that will lead to a brighter financial future. Whether you're an independent contractor, an employee, or a small business owner, understanding your tax obligations is crucial.

At Practice, we understand the challenges of managing taxes as a business owner. That's why we offer a powerful automation tool that can help you manage everything from finances to customer relations. Our automation system isn’t just a tool; it's your partner in efficient business management.

With Practice, you can navigate the complex world of business finances with ease. Whether you're a contractor or an employer, you're not alone in managing your business finances. Practice can help you stay on top of your taxes, manage your expenses, and track your income. Sign up for a free trial today and see how Practice can help you take your business to the next level.

Free content
Learn about our Teams tier
Track client fulfillment and manage your 1099s with ease

Delegate, collaborate, and oversee your client base across your team — without missing a step.

Give your clients a simple and professional experience

Practice has scheduling, payments, client management, file storage and more — all in one place.
Try for free

Simple client management designed for teams

Delegate, collaborate, and oversee your client base across your team — without missing a step.
Learn more
Are you a coach? Take our quiz to find out if Practice is a good fit for you
Get started
Get a simple and professional experience for you and your clients
Get started
Text Link